Saturday, 27 August 2016

The All Canadian All-Star Perplexity

The first reference I can recall seeing about a definite selection of the most impressive players from a particular season for the top level of Canadian football competition at the time, was from around 1912 but I can't locate the document or publication at the moment. Nevertheless it is a fitting indicator of the long and twisted and very poorly documented history of All-Star team selections in Canada. Naturally this aspect of the game has also resulted in a fair number of collectibles produced over the decades to be showcased here.


Canadian football Hall of Fame player and subsequent author, reporter, poet! and highly regarded knowledgeable expert on the sport, Ted Reeve selected this All-Star team for Liberty Magazine in 1938.

Independent selection of All-Eastern teams by the media appears to have began sometime in the late twenties with a more or less official Canadian Press team being announced from 1932 in the East and 1937 in the West. These teams were often featured as stories in the news magazines of the times (with colour accents!) and are attractive and historically interesting items.



Maclean's nominated their own All-Star team selected by a different sports reporter in 1938. It is not known if these various team selections were somehow merged to create the Canadian Press team or if they were independently determined. 

Maclean's magazine is of course well known here but others like Liberty and New Liberty are hard to track since internet searches of any kind are always inundated with the American versions of the magazine and almost no results about the Canadian. In general the wealth of obtainable information and pictures relating to Canadian football in vintage news magazines and newspaper supplement magazines has not been documented to any reasonable degree.


Ted Reeve's credibility in the sport allowed him to keep picking All-Star teams for more than 20 years, above is his 1950 effort. The players selected by the Canadian Press were eventually compiled as official in team media guides and the CFL official record books.

By the mid fifties specific football magazines targeted at fans were being produced and in some cases selecting their own "All-Canadian" teams as it seems the Canadian Press teams were still limited to just the IRFU team in the east and the WIFU team in the west.



Normie Kwong appears in his All-Star colours on the cover of Canadian Football Illustrated for 1956 and included was a story on the new innovation from 1955, the very first Canadian Football All-Star game.


From 1955 through 1958 four All-Star games pitted the East against the West sponsored by the Shriner hospitals for sick children. The games were played in Toronto, Vancouver, Montreal and Hamilton and all were in December meaning the weather conditions were usually a negative factor.



The official first All-Star souvenir program on the left and a much scaled-down 4 pager version on the right for the less well-heeled fans in attendance. Having different quality programs like this was fairly common in this era with the cheaper edition probably being harder to come by today.


The fifties All-Star games were not particularly well-attended and since so many of the players were American imports they would not all have normally stayed in the country anyways after the season was over. The games were discontinued after 1958 with the West claiming a 2-1 edge with one tie.




 The 1956 edition of the game featured some fairly funky little used logos on the program and other collectibles were starting to become available such as the pennant pictured above right. If you have a healthy collecting budget perhaps Hamilton's Eddie Bevan #52 game-worn All-Star jersey from 1956 would look good in your man cave.


From 1962 the Football Reporters of Canada began selecting an official All-Canadian team on Offence and Defense which corresponded with the recent adoption of an interlocking schedule among the two conferences.



Magazines would still sometimes publicize All-Star selections independently from the official selections. On the left is the 1963 French Canadian magazine Perspectives and on the right is a 1970 magazine with a Sports Canada "All-Pro" coaches selected team.


In 1970 the All-Star game was resurrected under the auspices of the CFL Players Association with the format being the previous season's All-Stars from all teams combining forces against the reigning Grey Cup Champions at the home field of the champions. 



On the left is the "1st Annual" (not really) program from 1970 and it is little known that this game was the last career game for Ottawa superstar QB Russ Jackson, not the 1969 Grey Cup game.  On the right is the inside of the CFLPA All-Star banquet pamphlet from the 1971 game in Montreal.


These games continued in the champs versus everybody else format for five years with all of the games happening in the pre-season. The League won 3 of the contests with the Stampeders and Rough Riders winning the other two. 



Occasionally you might come across a CFL All-Star reference in an unexpected place such as the colour game action picture from the 1972 contest at McMahon Stadium in a glossy magazine promoting the city of Calgary. At right are All-Star tickets from the 1972, 1974 and 1978 games.


In 1976 the format reverted to East (1 win) versus West (2 wins) for the next three years in pre-season, followed by a 4 year gap before another post season December game but this time indoors at brand spanking new B.C. Place Stadium (West win).



1978 All-Star program from Calgary and 1983 All-Star program from Vancouver 

The last CFL All-Star game was held in 1988 in June at Commonwealth Stadium where the CFL All-Stars defeated the reigning Grey Cup champion Eskimos. Of course CFL All-Star and All-Canadian team selection continued but in true Canadian Football fashion at some point the CFL Players Association began selecting their own All-Star team (voted on by the players themselves) meaning there were more than one group of selections in certain years.

There used to be a list of some years of these selections on one of the two CFLPA (and ProPlayers) websites and there used to be lists of the CFL selections on their website but they all seem to have disappeared now. These more modern All-Star teams spawned additional collectibles that I will cover in a future blog post.

Tuesday, 26 July 2016

ME-O MY-O OYO WHY-O?

OYO is the name of a modern small plastic sport figure / toy that has been on the market for several years now. As is sometimes the case with these sorts of products the CFL eventually became involved a few years after inception and there are now more CFL OYO's than you can shake a stick at out there to collect.

The figures are reminiscent of LEGO toy figures (except they are athletes and not pirates or Luke Skywalker) and so is the name OYO but of course for trademark purposes no direct reference to the other company's product is made (although it is stated that the figures are "compatible with most name brand building toys").


As with most things memorabilia these days Saskatchewan was the first team to harness the marketing power of OYO with a set of white uniform figures issued in 2013 


The first CFL figures were designated G1LE for Generation 1 Limited Edition (actual production figures are unknown) and as Series 1 but only Roughriders were available. The usual suspects were produced (Durant, Dressler, Sheets, Chick and presumably a few others). The figures are not actual likenesses of the players but are customized with the player's jersey number and name on the back and on the packaging material. Black and White figures are used depending on the player. Each player comes with a few accessories as well.



This was followed up by a dark jersey Saskatchewan Series 2 with a copyright year of 2013 as well 


In 2014 the line was expanded across all of the CFL teams but somewhat confusingly the figures for each of the other 8 teams were also designated G1LE Series 1. So it is not clear if the Series designation is for a separate issue of a given number of figures (per team, per year) or the Series number is incremented if a player is given a second figure (with the same team) in the same year or possibly also in a subsequent year.


  
Note that the initial figures for the other teams issued in 2014 have the same box design as the 2013 figures. Here is a "Series 1" Ricky Ray of Toronto.


Later in 2014 the box design was slightly modified with the 6+ child safety designation being moved to the back and the rest of the graphics remaining pretty much the same but some of the wording is removed as well. G1LE Series 1 they remain.



2014 Hamilton Simoni Lawrence with modified box design


2014 also saw the release of the first of what will likely be a large number of vintage players as well as team mascots, with the same modified box design.



 Doug Flutie and Ralph the Dog are immortalized in mini plastic form. Flutie is also available in his Stampeder uniform, unknown if a B.C. version exists.

For the 2015 season a few players that changed teams are available with the late 2014 box design and with 2015 as the copyright date on the back of the box. Presumably the players that were issued in 2014 also continued to be produced because there were plenty of them around for purchase.



Part of Kevin Glenn's sojourn through the CFL teams is available for collectors. Also pictured is a different box design for the Tiger-Cats mascot, it is unclear which year this was issued in but 2015 would be a reasonable guess.


2014 Also saw the arrival of larger Endzone playsets in specific team configurations. Priced around $30.00 - $35.00 they are still commonly available at team stores and on Ebay. Not sure whether or not there has been any evolution or changes to the endzone sets between 2014 and 2016.



These sets came with two generic players and a referee. 


These OYO figures are obviously a very successful product and they have a lucrative target market for something that requires just a little product and packaging customization to produce "different" players for consumers to buy. They are marketed at kids but how many 6+ year old kids are going to differentiate between all of these athletes, so there is definitely an adult team sport collector aspect to all of this. While it is good to have the CFL included in these product offerings there is a lot of redundancy to the line as well.

So 2016 rolls around and what is a company to do in order to generate more sales for these little action figures? Redesign the box and include a different accessory for the figure to "use". There might possibly also be some slight changes to the figure (I don't have any new ones to verify against the older models).


This new Ricky Ray is described on Ebay as Generation 2 Series 2 but the designation is not visible in these scans.  Would seem to indicate again that the series number changes per player figure per team.


Now with all of the CFL based product activity one might expect to be able to get a comprehensive list of CFL players and available products from the OYO website which is prominently printed on each box. Unfortunately (but not surprisingly) there is ZERO information on the CFL line on the website. An email to them inquiring about a CFL list indicated that they did not have one and directed me to the CFL website, which naturally also has ZERO information on the product, same goes for the CFLPA website. There is information on a few of the products on some of the team store websites so at least that is not a dead-end.


  
Here we have Chris Getzlaf with his new team listed as G2S1 so if that designation is accurate it may be further indication that the series number is per team (as Getzlaf had previous Rider figures) or it may be reset by Generation, it really is anybodies guess. G2 Solomon Elimimian appears to have wandered into the wrong locker room.



Also new for 2016 are accessory playsets such as the items pictured below - now with with CFL Stickers!




It would appear that the OYO trend is going to continue for a while as sales are likely strong (obviously led by the NFL, MLB and NHL licencees) and since it takes so little production line effort to swap the little buggers into CFL format we get to go along for the ride. They don't cost too much (between $12 and $15 each at full retail) for one or two if you are giving them to your kid to play with, but collecting a full team set can be pretty costly in the long run.

I have not decided yet if these should be catalogued as an addition to Volume I as they are technically player specific, or whether or not they should go into Volume 3 since they could also be considered effectively generic Novelties & Souvenirs. Anyway I need to go and buy my missing Generation X Series Infinity Ralph the Dog 3rd Jersey Limited Edition Dog Pound Playset Variant.





Wednesday, 29 June 2016

Magic ! From Space! - (Volume 1 Update)

The golden age of plastic toys occurred in the fifties and sixties when the versatile material overtook the traditional wood and metal as the primary component used to manufacture playthings for children (and of course thousands of other products). Couple this with the enthusiasm for all things relating to space thanks to the space race between the U.S. and the U.S.S.R and it kind of makes sense that a Canadian company that produced plastic novelties would call itself Space Magic LTD.


1963 Krun - chee CFL holder imprint on left and 1964 Nalleys CFL holder imprint on right 


But what does any of that have to do with Canadian Football? Well it seems that Space Magic was responsible for manufacturing all of the plastic cap holders that were made available for collectors to house their CFL plastic potato chip caps in both 1963 and 1964. The imprint was a little different between the two years as is evident above in the bottom central cap indentations.

When I published Collecting Canadian Football Volume I in 2013 I did not have a whole lot of information available about the holders and only two were pictured from 1963 and one from 1964. Additionally I made an assumption that in 1963 each team would have had its own colour of holder from each named potato chip manufacturer and I listed them that way although most colour/brand variations were unconfirmed. Naturally it makes perfect sense that an orderly mind would expect that a collector would want to put Eskimo caps in a dark green holder and Argo caps in a blue holder but examples of caps in holders where the owner made absolutely no attempt to enforce a proper colour correlation are disturbingly evident from time to time. That, coupled with the fact that all teams had more than one colour in their uniforms and also that there seemed to be more colours used for holders than teams means that those listings were incorrect or misleading at best,

To shed a little more light on the subject I am featuring at least one of each brand of holder that I have information on in this blog post, along with a few peculiarities.


1963 Krun - chee Black CFL holder : KRUN - CHEE Canadian Football Stars 


Although each of the 1963 holders had the same attractive football layout design, the brand name of course was different for each manufacturer and the sub-title was either a different phrase or had a different juxtaposition of the wording.


1963 Hunters Dark Blue CFL holder : Hunters Canadian Football Stars 


Humpty Dumpty holders seem to be few and far between as this is the only example I have seen a scan of. Note that the holder is bilingual which corresponds with the bilingual Humpty Dumpty caps but not with the no-name caps which were both unilingual and bilingual and no-name caps are known to have been available in Humpty Dumpty chip bags.


1963 Humpty Dumpty Gold CFL holder : Humpty Dumpty Football Plaque - Plaque A Jetons 


At first glance at the holder below it appears that all is in karmic balance as the conscientious long ago collector put his B.C. Lions caps with their black and orange uniforms palette into an appropriate black holder. But wait, these are in fact 1964 Nalley's caps inserted into the holder designed for the 1963 issue so undoubtedly some type of negative repercussions eventually manifested themselves in the life of the foolhardy offender.
    
       
1963 Nalley's Black CFL holder : Nalley's Pro Football Stars Of Canada 


For 1964 only Nalley's issued potato chip caps for the five western teams and it is thought that there were just five colour matched holders produced with a new field design, although I cannot recall actually seeing any more than the blue and green versions, so perhaps the other three team holders listed in Volume I should have been marked in lighter text as unconfirmed.


1964 Nalley's Blue CFL holder : Nalley's Pro Football Stars Of Canada 


Another error in Volume I was the statement that the 1964 Nalley's cap holders were identical to the 1963 versions except for the caption, but the above two images makes it clear that wasn't the case. For unknown reasons the subtitle for the green holder was different as per below, and for the remainder of the 1964 holders it is still a mystery, perhaps both versions exist in all colours?


1964 Nalley's Green CFL holder : Nalley's 1964 Western Conference Pro Football Stars


It is one of the oddities of classic CFL collectibles as to why no ephemera of these chip cap promotions seems to have survived, after all you would think the packaging would have advertised the premiums inside, the shields would have had order forms or there would have been in grocery store displays for the products. Well the following two images would appear to be just that with regards to the wall plaques. (I was using the term holders in the guide and this blog entry, but now might be a good time to start using the official designation).


1964 Nalley's Wall Plaque packaging illustrations, not to scale, sizes unknown, blank backed


The left illustration matches the green shield for subtitle and the players actually look distinguishable but I have not compared them to any of the 1964 caps to see which team, if any they are modeled on. The player images on the right illustration are generic and the subtitle is gibberish letters. Both pieces look to have been cut from a larger package. These came up on ebay a few years ago and interest was surprisingly low if I recall correctly.

Space Magic was also apparently involved in producing a series of space caps and probably the related wall plaques and perhaps that is where the name originally came from. There is a posting on the Topps Archives from last year that has some more information on Space Magic and some of the other promotions they were involved with here Space Patrol.






 

Sunday, 29 May 2016

Posterpalooza!

As I have mentioned before in an earlier post relating to the Saskatchewan Roughrider's 1989 Collector Series , posters are one of the most ephemeral of ephemera for a variety of reasons and as such relatively few survive long and that means many are forgotten and uncatalogued. This post will examine a few of the posters that have come to light since the publication of Collecting Canadian Football Volumes 1 and 2. All of these will hopefully make their way into a catalogue update or one of the proposed Volumes 3 or 4 at some point in the future. 


Early 1970's Generic Saskatchewan poster at left and
 early or mid 1970's B.C. Lions team helmet poster at right

The Roughrider poster is probably (but not certainly) unique to that franchise as it was issued by Al Benecick Enterprises which would obviously have been a venture of Hall of Famer Roughrider player Al Benecick. His career lasted until 1969 so the seventies date assignment is an educated guess. This item bounced around ebay for a while before finding a home. The Lions helmet poster is one of three western team half size posters that were on ebay a few years back, all western teams so presumably a set of 5 were available at one time. Nice item and unusual to see the single bar helmet graphic of this era facing left instead of right.



Late 1970's All-Pro Countdown poster at left and
close up of some of the player vignettes at right 

All-Pro countdown was a sponsored promotion of General Tire in the late seventies and various promotional items were produced in conjunction with a weekly TV show where CFL stars would compete in physical football related challenges, hosted by then CFL play-by-play TV announcer Pat Marsden. Interestingly the small player images obviously all come from the same posed photographic sessions and some of these exact same images (only wider in scope) were used for the extremely rare Nalley's 1976 Chips cards for the Calgary and Edmonton players.



Rothmans 1981 CFL Stars poster in English at left and
same Rothmans 1981 Les Etoiles LCF in French at right 

Gotta love tobacco sponsored issues and the above pictured Rothmans posters were issued in both French and English as standalone posters on white glossy stock (above left) and as center pages on magazine newsprint (above right) and for multiple years so there are lots of variations to collect of this interesting uncatalogued issue.



Late 80's or possibly early 90's Hamilton Tiger-Cats Molson Cup poster at left and
mid or late 80's Toronto Argonauts action poster at right

While a lot of poster action happened out west the Eastern teams were not completely dormant as the above two team specific items show. The Molson Cup was promoted for every team (and hockey teams, of course) so there many be similar or related posters available for the other CFL franchises but the Toronto poster was probably team issued. Whether the players represent recognizable athletes or are completely generic, has not been elaborated yet. 



CBC Winnipeg Blue Bombers 1992 Get On-Side poster at left and
CBC Calgary Stampeders 1993 In Your Face! poster at right

CBC issued at least two promotional poster sets celebrating their participation in CFL broadcasting in the early nineties. I have seen posters of these designs for other teams as well so presumably both sets include items for each franchise.



CFL 1994 All-Star Ski Team poster at left and
Family Funfest 1995 Grey Cup Activity poster at right

Sometimes CFL posters are not at all what you might expect as the multi sponsor Ski poster nicely illustrates. The Grey Cup activity poster shows the league at its all time maximum franchise level (13) that is certainly not likely to be surpassed anytime this century or possibly not in the next either. One notable aspect that has not yet found its way into any of the Collecting Canadian Football volumes are the official Grey Cup posters that were produced for each season's championship game from an indeterminate year forwards.




2000s Reebok What's Your Colour? League Wide promotional poster at top
2000's or early 2010's Reebok Reediscover Saskatchewan Roughriders poster at bottom

Some of the more difficult to get your hands on posters are those issued starting earlier this century by the league's promotional equipment and jersey partners.These were typically displayed at team stores and promotional league events and besides the posters there were other types of ephemera made over numerous years of the sponsorships. These sets and items are not well documented at the present time. The pictures above are not to scale and the Durant is a much larger stand-up style of hard backed poster than the top item.



2014 Geroy Simon B.C. Lions tribute night poster at left and
2014 Nick Moore Winnipeg Blue Bombers Co-op promotional poster at right

Player specific posters are also still being produced, but you have to be at the right place at the right time if you want to score them for free. The Simon poster was handed out at a specific Geroy Simon night at B.C. place stadium after he had retired and the Moore poster was part of a set of promotional items manufactured to popularize specific co-op products in a program that has been running in the west for three or four years now and spans all of the prairie teams where co-op grocery stores operate.

One thing is for sure, even in this digital age CFL posters continue to proliferate, and when you see one it will be here today and gone tomorrow.

Friday, 29 April 2016

We Regret To Inform You...

Some things never change, or at least never changed for decades, and one of those things was having the initiative to reach out to the professional football clubs in existence at the time, in search of a job, banging heads, in a foreign country if need be, to either put food on the table or to continue chasing your dream.

Luckily the process involved in promoting yourself as a capable prospect for a team in need of your particular gridiron skills, would generate ephemera in the form of letters and envelopes (covers in the collecting vernacular of philately), some of which have survived offering fascinating time capsule glimpses of the era.



1953 Edmonton Eskimo letterhead with hand written rejection letter and 1953 Calgary Stampeder letterhead with typed rejection letter. Both feature great vintage logos and word marks.


One such case played out in 1953 when lineman Karl Giesler sent letters to multiple CFL clubs looking for an expenses paid tryout. Giesler played at Pepperdine University and random internet information credits him with time at Green Bay and Washington in the NFL as well but I can't find any record of him playing regular season NFL games in the Total Football II reference guide.



The associated covers the letters were mailed in also feature the vintage logos and word marks but with some variation on the Edmonton cover.


By reading these letters (and doing some persistent googling) you can get a pretty good micro summary of Karl's career (I have scanned the letters at a higher resolution than normal for the blog images so you can click on them to get a larger view). The Tiger-Cats at least offered to allow him to come to camp and if he made the team he would be reimbursed expenses, which apparently he didn't as there is no record of him playing in the CFL either.



Giesler's 1953 rejection letters from the Winnipeg Blue Bombers and the Hamilton Tiger-Cats. The Bomber letterhead is very plain (some glue residue creating the comet effect) but the Tiger-Cat letterhead has a superb real image of a tiger's head that differs from the traditional logo. 


These letters can also be worth considerable sums of money for those that collect autographs of football players and administrators. The Bomber letter is signed by head coach George Trafton who was previously a hard rock perennial All-Star and eventual Hall of Famer with the leather helmet era Chicago Bears. I believe I read somewhere that it was Trafton that severely injured former teammate Red Grange in 1927, a hit from which the superstar Grange never completely recovered his former form. It is another example of the overlapping of Canadian and American football legacies due to the peculiar nature of the historical intertwining of the two sports.



Both the Hamilton and Winnipeg 1953 covers are about as plain as they can be.


Flash forward more than twenty years to 1976 and another hopeful player, Chuck Slater is also sending letters to CFL clubs in search of on field employment. Unfortunately for Chuck there is no record of him having played professional football in either the CFL or NFL either.



Montreal Alouette 1976 letterhead and Hamilton Tiger-Cat 1976 letterhead. The stationary was a little more reserved in the seventies, but still interesting. 


Here are two Ottawa letterhead versions, the first from 1976 being Chuck's PFO letter and one from four years earlier showing the slight evolution of the graphic design of the top header from monochrome to two colour.

These types of items appear on Ebay every now and then and are often fairly reasonably priced since this type of memorabilia is not heavily sought after by most collectors.



Here are the respective covers from 1976 with the Montreal and Ottawa items featuring colourful designs, but the Hamilton item is almost identical to the 1953 version. However of interest is the custom meter cancellation promoting Canadian Football as Canada's Most Exciting Sport. 



1966 Hamilton Tiger-Cat Commemorative Cover and 1962 Winnipeg Blue Bomber colourful vintage logo cover with custom meter cancellation 


Lest you think Hamilton and Winnipeg always had drab covers for their correspondence, above are two more stylistic examples. Somewhat unusually the same Most Exciting Sport slogan is used for the Winnipeg metered cancellation in a different design, but a full 14 years before the Tiger-Cat example. Hard to believe somebody coordinated that promotional slogan across multiple teams over that time span, maybe just a crazy coincidence.



1957 Toronto Argonaut letterhead with nice double blue colour scheme and great player graphic and 1963 B.C. Lion letterhead with classic mountain lion logo over Empire Stadium schematic drawing.


Finally above are two attractive vintage letters from two of the clubs not represented in the earlier images. There are undoubtedly many more unique items out there waiting to be be rediscovered, similar to those presented in this blog post. Just another fascinating aspect of CFL history that can be collected and enjoyed.

Sunday, 27 March 2016

Fifties Flatland Frenzy

In 1951 the Saskatchewan Roughriders advanced to their first Grey Cup of the modern post war era. The franchise had competed in seven Dominion championships but had lost them all and it was hard to say what was worse - the 54-0 thrashing in their first appearance in 1923 as the Regina Rugby Club, or their string of five straight Grey Cup defeats as the Regina Roughriders from 1928 through 1932. On top of that the 1936 team, that some contemporary observers felt was the strongest in the country, was denied a chance to compete for the championship because of Eastern football governing body rule machinations related to the number of U.S. imports allowed to participate. So when the team finally returned to the big game, the province went into overdrive promoting and supporting their heroes.
 

On the left is a 1951 Saskatchewan Roughriders game program. These programs were typically very thick for their era because the team depended on community business support and many pages were devoted to sponsor advertisements. On the right is some snappy songwriting promoted by star quarterback Glenn Dobbs. 


From a memorabilia perspective the team produced their standard game programs in 1951 as well as the odd other piece such as the official team song sheet music (actually not 100% sure that this dates to 1951, might be a bit later). It might seem strange that the team quarterback Dobbs would be hosting a radio show while playing but Dobbs was widely regarded as the most popular man in the province and all efforts to promote the team were undertaken.



This colourful pamphlet with team photo inside was listed in Collecting Canadian Football Volume II. A few years back an ebay lot included an actual photograph of this team shot that was used to produce the brochure, which would be considerably rarer than the more mass produced item.


Once the team had qualified for the Grey Cup (by virtue of a nail biting 19-18 best of three rubber match victory at home versus Edmonton) they started producing ephemera that focused attention on the province's three biggest assets - Wheat, the Roughriders and the Mounties.



This broadsheet was mass produced promoting the province's role as a food producer, and just to be absolutely sure the rest of Canada knew about Saskatchewan wheat actual small loaves of bread with an attractive insert were baked and shrink wrapped. The die-cut ribbon-ed decoration reinforces the wheat - football team tie in again. 


One gets the feeling that as jubilant as the province was to be going back to the Cup, they were somewhat guarded about their chances, perhaps with the multiple disappointments of previous attempts still in mind. Thanks to Rider super fan Warren Welte for the loaf of bread image above.



This spectacularly evocative placemat is dated 1951 and clearly was themed for the Grey Cup quest with those three Saskatchewan assets prominently portrayed.


The beautiful placemat above was on ebay just recently and I was somewhat shocked that it did not bring a higher final bid (around $15 I think, the last time I checked it) because it would be rated an extremely rare fairly fragile item to have survived and it is so quintessentially Saskatchewan and Roughrider focused. While their are definitely some Rider super fans/collectors that have impressive team memorabilia shrines, I sometimes wonder if a lot of their huge current fanbase has little affinity or appreciation for the history of the club and the on and off-field struggles they went through during decades of lackluster results.
    


At left is the 1st edition of the 1951 Grey Cup News and at right is the 4th and final edition. The newsletter was printed on the "Green Train" to Toronto for the big game.


In an earlier post relating to team news publications I noted the existence of the above pictured Saskatchewan Grey Cup News sheets and upon closer examination (although the images above are unfortunately a little too grainy to tell) it appears there were 4 in all produced on-route by the team delegation heading east. What a great historical record of the championship excitement and hoopla a full set of these would make!




The Grey Cup program front cover design was rather unimaginatively the same for each of the
1949 through 1952 cup games. 


Well the big day finally arrived and team supporters from both sides could purchase the 1951 game program at the stadium. Rider fan's (western ones anyway) dreams were destined to be dashed once again as the Ottawa Rough Riders prevailed 21-14.



A nine! record set of 78's (that's the RPM - revolution per minute speed designation for you internet age kiddies...) of the radio broadcast of the team homecoming celebrations


Despite the loss the province was still upbeat about their hometown heroes, so much so that the homecoming celebration at Regina Exhibition Stadium (which is actually an indoor arena, apparently the oldest still standing in use hockey arena in Canada) was recorded and a large record set pressed for posterity. The celebration featured player introductions with roaring crowd and speeches by dignitaries of the day. The set features attractive packaging and era evocative football graphics on the records and the one pictured at right was presented to player Bill Clarke by the premier's office. It is unknown how may sets were pressed and if they were just handed out to team members and officials or if they were made available to the general public as well, possibly both. Either way this is a great memorabilia piece for Roughrider collectors.




Note that the Ottawa Rough Rider 1951 game programs (actually since at least 1948) used the much nicer full coloured more detailed graphics that were the original source for those used for the Grey Cup programs of the era.

   
On the Ottawa side the number of collectibles from that year is somewhat less expansive (although there is a great 12 item Rough Rider team issue printed picture set catalogued in Collecting Canadian Football Volume II), but they definitely managed to produce the most satisfying piece of football ephemera for 1951 pictured above right.